Massachusetts Supreme Judicial CourtJan 7, 2011
Ibanez: the foreclosures were void
In U.S. Bank National Association v. Ibanez, 458 Mass. 637 (2011), U.S. Bank, as trustee for a securitization trust, foreclosed and then asked the Land Court to declare its title clear. The courts refused: U.S. Bank could not show it held the mortgage when it foreclosed. The evidence included assignments executed “in blank” — naming no assignee at all — and an assignment dated more than a year after the sale. The Supreme Judicial Court held that an assignment in blank “conveys nothing and is void,” that a foreclosing party must hold the mortgage at the time of the notice and the sale, and that a post-sale assignment cannot cure the defect. The foreclosure was wholly void.
Read the Ibanez opinion ↗
The chain inside the caseCourt record
The broken chain ran through Option One
The Ibanez mortgage's own paper trail, as recited in the case, ran from the originator through Option One Mortgage on assignments in blank — blank in, blank out — before the loan was pooled into the trust U.S. Bank served as trustee for. In other words, the defining standing case of the foreclosure crisis is, on its own record, a story about a chain of empty assignments ending at a trustee that foreclosed anyway. The consolidated companion case in the same opinion involved a trust built from Option One loans as well (ABFC 2005-OPT 1). One broken chain, documented end to end, in the leading case.
Read the Ibanez opinion ↗
OCC consent orderApr 13, 2011
One of the eight servicers ordered to overhaul
In the same interagency sweep that hit Citi, the OCC issued Consent Order AA-EC-11-18 against U.S. Bank National Association and U.S. Bank National Association ND, finding deficiencies and unsafe or unsound practices in residential mortgage servicing and in the initiation and handling of foreclosure proceedings across a portfolio of some 1,400,000 loans. The order required a comprehensive action plan, effective servicing, foreclosure, and loss-mitigation operations, and an independent review of 2009–2010 foreclosures. The bank neither admitted nor denied the findings.
Read the OCC order (PDF) ↗
OCC civil money penaltyFeb 9, 2016
$10 million for not fixing it on time
Five years on, the OCC found U.S. Bank had failed to correct the 2011 deficiencies in a timely fashion and had violated the 2011 consent order from October 1, 2014 through August 30, 2015. The OCC assessed a $10 million civil money penalty, imposed business restrictions in the interim, and terminated the order only after determining the bank had come into compliance. Santander was penalized in the same action; several other 2011 servicers had already been released the previous summer.
Read the OCC's 2016 release (PDF) ↗