Fraud Bugs cockroach badge Fraud Bugsfraudbugs.com · Independent evidence desk

Case 02 · Howards Van Lines

The public complaint record

Howards Vanlines Inc, a Garfield, New Jersey company classified by the BBB as a moving broker, drew a reported surge of complaints in 2025–2026 — most of them in a single year — centered on prices jumping, belongings allegedly held, damage claims that could not be filed, and customers who say they were cut off when they tried to claim or complain. Every count below is a reported count attributed to its source — the BBB profile, an analysis of FMCSA Complaint Center data by Trunk, or a named news outlet — not an adjudicated finding by this hub. Compiled November 7, 2026, from the public sources listed below; figures are as reported by each source on that date.

Reported counts, not findings.

Complaint volume shows what consumers reported to the BBB, to the federal complaint center, and to reporters. It is not a court ruling, and this hub does not treat it as one. Where reports conflict — including on why the company lost its federal operating authority — both versions are printed below and neither is endorsed.

106Complaints on the company’s BBB profile in the last 3 years, as reported by the BBB — 103 of them in the last 12 months. The profile carries a BBB alert.
103Of those BBB complaints, the number filed in just the last 12 months, per the BBB profile.
206Complaints counted by Trunk’s analysis of FMCSA Complaint Center data, October 2025 through October 2026 — 197 of them in 2026 alone.
87“Hostage goods” complaints in July 2026 alone — the peak month in that FMCSA-data analysis, and its largest single category.

Company identifiers

  • Company: Howards Vanlines Inc, Garfield, NJ.
  • USDOT 4391903 · MC 1722990
  • BBB address: 254 Palisade Ave, PO Box 28, Garfield, NJ 07026.
  • Federal registration address: 141 Lanza Ave, Garfield, NJ 07026.
  • BBB categories: Moving Brokers and Movers — the BBB classifies it as a broker, even though customers report being told it was not one.
  • BBB file opened: October 23, 2025. Business started: April 1, 2025.
  • FMCSA-registered: September 2025, with a fleet of one registered truck (per Trunk’s analysis of FMCSA records).
  • Federal status: as of October 2026, no longer FMCSA-authorized to operate. Reports conflict on why — see “Two versions of the authority loss” below.
  • Not the same company: Howard’s Van Line, Inc. of Dayton, Ohio is a different business with a similar name.

Recurring themes, as reported

  • Price increased on moving day. BBB complaints repeat the pattern — one reports +$2,500 with no choice but to pay.
  • Goods held. “Hostage goods” is the largest category in the FMCSA-data analysis. The Arizona Attorney General’s office has publicly called this pattern a “hostage load” and illegal.
  • Delivery delays. One BBB complaint reports delivery taking 31 days against a promised 5.
  • Claims that could not be filed. Customers report damage claims that could not be filed.
  • Told it was not a broker. Customers report being told the company was not a broker while other companies handled their goods.
  • Contact cut off. A customer sent 9 requests for a final bill of lading before the company blocked her emails and calls, per the BBB complaint record.

Complaints on file, by source

Federal, BBB, states & news

Each source is kept separate below, with its own counts and wording, so a reported figure is never presented as this hub’s finding.

Federal — FMCSA / U.S. DOT

  • 206 complaints filed with the FMCSA Complaint Center (formerly the National Consumer Complaint Database) from October 2025 through October 2026 — 9 in late 2025, then 197 in 2026 alone (analysis of FMCSA data by Trunk, trunk.lorea.ai). That is reported as the highest per-truck complaint rate in the FMCSA database, from a company with one registered truck.
  • The largest category was hostage goods — belongings allegedly held until customers paid more — peaking at 87 complaints in July 2026 alone.
  • FMCSA began investigating in August 2026; investigators who visited the registered Garfield address found a virtual office, not a bona fide office (per Trunk).
  • FOX 10 Phoenix reported the company as under federal investigation by the U.S. Department of Transportation.

Better Business Bureau

  • 106 complaints in the last 3 years — 103 of them in the last 12 months (BBB profile, Garfield, NJ).
  • The BBB profile carries an alert, and many complaints are marked “BBB is unable to locate the business.”
  • Recurring BBB complaint themes: price increased on moving day (one reports +$2,500 with no choice but to pay), delivery taking 31 days against a promised 5, damage claims that could not be filed, customers told the company was not a broker while other companies handled their goods, and a customer who sent 9 requests for a final bill of lading before the company blocked her emails and calls.

State attorneys general

The Arizona Attorney General’s Office publicly described this pattern as a “hostage load” — “They will take your stuff and then refuse to deliver it or refuse to unload it unless you pay them more money. That’s against the law.” (FOX 10 Phoenix)

Consumers report filing with the New York and New Jersey attorneys general, plus complaints in Arizona, Georgia, and Arkansas and with federal agencies (per FOX 10 and consumer posts).

News investigations

  • KMBC 9 (Kansas City): investigated the operation, including an August 2026 Leavenworth County, Kansas eviction case involving a warehouse (leased by Logistic Moving Services LLC) holding consumers’ belongings from moves arranged through Howards and related companies.
  • FOX 10 (Phoenix): investigated an Arizona couple whose belongings were stranded; reported nearly 200 complaints in 2025–2026 and the federal investigation.
  • ABC7 New York: investigative coverage referenced in Trunk’s reporting.

Conflicting reports

Two versions of the authority loss

Reporting agrees on the outcome — as of October 2026 the company is no longer FMCSA-authorized to operate, and FMCSA began investigating in August 2026 — but not on the reason. This hub keeps both versions and does not pick one.

Version one — authority revoked

Wisevoter (Oct 15, 2026) reported the DOT revoked its operating authority after nearly 200 complaints. FOX 10 Phoenix likewise reported the company under federal investigation by the U.S. Department of Transportation.

Version two — authority lapsed

Trunk’s analysis says the authority ended through an insurance cancellation rather than an enforcement action — the authority lapsed via insurance cancellation. Either way, the federal listing shows it as not authorized.

Fraud Bugs wanted-poster artwork: a cockroach in a vintage poster frame, FRAUD above and BUGS below
Fraud Bugs · Case file poster

Reported timeline

April 1, 2025

Business started, per the BBB profile. BBB file opened October 23, 2025.

September 2025

FMCSA-registered, with one registered truck (per Trunk’s analysis of FMCSA records).

Oct 2025 – Oct 2026

Trunk’s analysis of FMCSA Complaint Center data counts 206 complaints in this window, 197 of them in 2026 alone, from a company with one registered truck.

April 23, 2026

Job HV4612419: the customer paid a $1,107.54 deposit by debit card, as detailed in the current case above.

July 2026

“Hostage goods” complaints peak at 87 in a single month, per that analysis. A July 2026 screenshot of the Google profile shows 1.0 stars after fake reviews were stripped.

August 2026

FMCSA began investigating, per the reporting summarized here. KMBC 9 reported the Leavenworth County warehouse / eviction case in this period.

October 2026

The company is no longer federally authorized to operate. Reports conflict on whether the authority was revoked or lapsed — both versions are kept above.

Review platforms — and the fake-review problem

  • Trustpilot: page after page of one-star accounts describing the same pattern — low quote, upcharge at pickup, weeks of silence, damaged or lost items, impossible claims process. Reviewers call it “out of business” as of mid-2026.
  • Google: after an investigator documented manipulation, Google stripped the company’s fake reviews, leaving a 1-star listing (per Trunk); a July 2026 screenshot of the Google profile shows 1.0 stars.
  • MyMovingJourney.com shows Howards at 4.7/5 from ~606 reviews — and was identified in Trunk’s Howards investigation as one of the fake review sites used to inflate the company’s ratings.
  • EIN Presswire campaign: Trunk also documented a paid EIN Presswire campaign flooding Google with positive press releases to push real complaints, Reddit threads, Facebook posts, and news coverage down in search results — documented as flooding Google with positive press releases to bury real complaints.

MyMovingJourney is a review platform, not a moving company, and it is named here only in that role.

Related companies named in reporting

Named in reporting: Trunk’s investigation and consumer accounts connect the operator (named in reporting as Moran Eli Hasut, also reported as Elad Hasut / Eli Davis / Allan Davis) and this complaint pattern to the companies below. This hub keeps the “named in reporting” framing exactly and does not present the connection as an adjudicated finding.

  • Handle With Care Moving and Transportation LLC (DOT 3190967, Tucker, GA — authority revoked three times)
  • Spirit Van Lines (Colorado)
  • Logistic Moving Services LLC (the Leavenworth warehouse company)
  • JCS Moving and Storage
  • Menards Moving and Storage LLC (DOT 4072455, Florida broker)
  • David and Goliath Moving and Storage
  • “Shannon’s Best Price Moving” — per a Trustpilot reviewer, described as a sister company; the reviewer reported being handed to it.

If this happened to you

File with the FMCSA Complaint Center, the BBB, your state attorney general, and ReportFraud.ftc.gov — and dispute the charge with your bank. Keep every text, email, and the cancellation policy you were given.

FMCSA Complaint Center

The federal complaint center for household-goods movers and brokers — nccdb.fmcsa.dot.gov. File with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration and keep your confirmation.

Better Business Bureau

File on the company’s BBB profile so your complaint joins the counted record. BBB is not a government agency and does not adjudicate legal claims.

Start a BBB complaint ↗

Your state attorney general

State consumer protection offices take moving and “hostage load” complaints; filings with the New York and New Jersey AGs are already reported by consumers in this case.

USA.gov consumer complaint guide ↗

ReportFraud.ftc.gov

File a report with the Federal Trade Commission at ReportFraud.ftc.gov.

Dispute the charge with your bank

Dispute the charge with your bank, and keep every text, email, and the cancellation policy you were given.

Sources for this section: BBB profile & complaints — bbb.org/us/nj/garfield/profile/moving-brokers/howards-vanlines-0221-90239349; Trunk investigation (FMCSA data analysis) — trunk.lorea.ai/insights/deep-dive-howards-vanlines and /insights/fraud-network-nj-ga-ks-pipeline; Wisevoter, “Department of Transportation Revokes Howards Vanlines License,” Oct 15, 2026; FOX 10 Phoenix, “How a reported hostage load moving scam stranded an Arizona couple’s belongings”; Trustpilot — trustpilot.com/review/howardsvanline.com; plus KMBC 9 (Kansas City) and ABC7 New York as referenced in Trunk’s reporting. Counts are reported counts, not findings.

Fairness policy

Corrections & company responses

Evidence can change the record.

If you are the subject of a published complaint, you may request a correction or submit a response. Identify the source card and provide a precise factual correction with supporting public documentation. The same email workflow below is used so the site does not falsely imply server-side submission.

Email a correction or response